A new era of neurotechnology means we may need new protections to safeguard our brain and mental experiences.
A last bastion of privacy, our brains have remained inviolate, even as sensors now record our heartbeats, breaths, steps and sleep. All that is about to change. An avalanche of brain-tracking devices—earbuds, headphones, headbands, watches and even wearable tattoos—will soon enter the market, promising to transform our lives. And threatening to breach the refuge of our minds.
Tech titans Meta, Snap, Microsoft and Apple are already investing heavily in brain wearables. They aim to embed brain sensors into smart watches, earbuds, headsets and sleep aids. Integrating them into our everyday lives could revolutionize health care, enabling early diagnosis and personalized treatment of conditions such as depression, epilepsy and even cognitive decline. Brain sensors could improve our ability to meditate, focus and even communicate with a seamless technological telepathy—using the power of thoughts and emotion to drive our interaction with augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR) headsets, or even type on virtual keyboards with our minds.
But brain wearables also pose very real risks to mental privacy, freedom of thought and self-determination. As these devices proliferate, they will generate vast amounts of neural data, creating an intimate window into our brain states, emotions and even memories. We need the individual power to shutter this new view into our inner selves.
Employers already seek out such data, tracking worker fatigue levels and offering brain wellness programs to mitigate stress, via platforms that give them unprecedented access to employees’ brains. Cognitive and emotional testing based on neuroscience is becoming a new job screening norm, revealing personality aspects that may have little to do with a job. In China, train conductors of the Beijing-Shanghai line, the busiest of its kind in the world, wear brain sensors throughout their work day. There are even reports of Chinese employees being sent home if their brain activity shows less than stellar brain metrics. As companies embrace brain wearables that can track employees’ attention, focus and even boredom, without safeguards in place, they could trample on employee’s mental privacy, eroding trust and well-being along with the dignity of work itself.
Governments, too, are seeking access to our brains, with a U.S brain initiative seeking “‘every spike from every neuron’ in the human brain,” to reveal “how the firing of these neurons produced complex thoughts.” While aimed at the underlying causes of neurological and psychiatric conditions, this same investment could also enable government interference with freedom of thought—a freedom critical to human flourishing. From functional brain biometric programs under development to authenticate individuals—including those funded by the National Science Foundation at Binghamton University—to so-called brain-fingerprinting techniques used to interrogate criminal suspects—sold by companies like Brainwave Science and funded by law enforcement agencies from Singapore to Australia to the United Arab Emirates—we must act quickly to ensure neurotechnology benefits humanity rather than heralding an Orwellian future of spying on our brains.
The rush to hack the human brain veers from neuromarketing to the rabbit hole of social media and even to cognitive warfare programs designed to disable or disorient. These technologies should have our full attention. Neuromarketing campaigns such as one conducted by Frito-Lays used insights about how women’s brains could affect snacking decisions, then monitored brain activity while people viewed their newly designed advertisements, allowing them to fine-tune their campaigns to better capture attention and drive women to snack more on their products. Social media “like” buttons and notifications are features designed to draw us habitually back to platforms, exploiting our brains’ reward systems. Clickbait headlines and pseudoscience claims prey on our cognitive biases, hobbling critical thinking. And nations worldwide are considering possible military applications of neuroscience, which some planners call warfare’s “sixth domain” (adding to a list that includes land, sea, air, space and cyberspace).
As brain wearables and artificial intelligences advance, the line between human agency and machine intervention will also blur. When a wearable reshapes our thoughts and emotions, how much of our actions and decisions remain truly our own? As we begin to offload mental tasks to AI, we risk becoming overly dependent on technology, weakening independent thought and even our capacity for reflective decision-making. Should we allow AI to shape our brains and mental experiences? And how do we retain our humanity in an increasingly interconnected world remade by these two technologies?
Malicious use and even hacking of brain wearables is another threat. From probing for information, to intercepting our PIN numbers as we think or type them, neural cybersecurity will rule. Imagine a world where brain wearables can track what we read and see, alter perceptions, manipulate emotions or even trigger physical pain. That’s a world that may soon arrive. Already, companies including China’s Entertech have accumulated millions of raw EEG data recordings from individuals across the world using its popular consumer-based brain wearables, along with personal information and device and app usage by those individuals. Entertech makes plain in their privacy policy they also record personal information, GPS signals, device sensors, computers and services a person is using, including websites they may be visiting. We must ensure that brain wearables are designed with security in mind and with device and data safeguards in place to mitigate these risks.
We stand at an inflection point in the beginning of a brain wearable revolution. We need prudent vigilance and an open and honest debate about the risks and benefits of neurotechnology, to ensure it is used responsibly and ethically. With the right safeguards, neurotechnology could be truly empowering for individuals. To get there will require we recognize new digital age rights to preserve our cognitive liberty—self-determination over our brains and mental experiences. We must do so now, before the choice is no longer ours to make.
This is an opinion and analysis article, and the views expressed by the author or authors are not necessarily those of Scientific American.
News
Cancer Mystery Solved: Scientists Discover How Melanoma Becomes “Immortal”
Scientists have uncovered a previously overlooked mechanism that may help melanoma cells become effectively “immortal.” Cancer cells face a major problem before they can become deadly: They have to figure out how to stop [...]
How Visual Neurons Organize Thousands of Synaptic Inputs
Summary: A new study uncovered the organizational rules that determine how neurons in the primary visual cortex process information. By imaging both the cell bodies (soma) and the individual synapses (on dendritic spines) of [...]
Scientists Just Found a Surprising Way To Destroy “Forever Chemicals”
Scientists have uncovered a new mechanism that may help break down highly persistent PFAS pollutants. PFAS have earned the nickname “forever chemicals” for a reason. These industrial compounds are so chemically durable that they [...]
Scientists Discover Cheap Material That Kills Deadly Superbugs
A new sulfur-rich antimicrobial polymer shows strong effectiveness against fungal and bacterial pathogens and may offer an affordable solution to antimicrobial resistance. Antimicrobial resistance is creating growing challenges for both healthcare and food production, [...]
What to Know About Cicada, or BA.3.2, the Latest SARS-CoV-2 Variant Under Monitoring
Like periodical cicadas, the insects for which it is nicknamed, SARS-CoV-2 Omicron subvariant BA.3.2 is only just beginning to emerge after lying low for an extended period since it first appeared. Although it was [...]
Scientists Say This Simple Supplement May Actually Reverse Heart Disease
Scientists in Japan say a common supplement may actually help “unclog” certain diseased heart arteries from the inside out. A simple food supplement sold in Japan may have helped reverse a dangerous form of [...]
New breakthrough against radiation: Korean Scientists create revolutionary shield with nanotechnology
Korean Scientists develop new nanotechnology material capable of reducing radiation impacts in space missions, hospitals, and power plants. The search for more efficient protection technologies in extreme environments has just gained an important advance. Korean [...]
Scientists Just Discovered the Hidden Trick That Keeps Your Cells Alive
A strange bead-like motion inside cells may be the secret to keeping their DNA—and health—in balance. Mitochondria are often described as the power plants of the cell because they produce the energy cells need [...]
Scientists Discover Stem Cells That Could Regrow Teeth and Bone
Scientists just uncovered the cellular “blueprint” that could one day let us regrow real teeth. Researchers at Science Tokyo have uncovered two distinct stem cell lineages that play a central role in forming tooth [...]
Scientists Uncover Fatal Weakness in “Zombie Cells” Linked to Cancer
A newly identified weakness in “zombie” cells may open the door to more precise cancer treatments by turning their own survival strategy against them. A new class of drugs takes advantage of a recently [...]
Bowel and Ovarian Cancers Are Dramatically Rising in Young Adults, Scientists Aren’t Sure Why
Cancer incidence is increasing, especially among younger adults, and current risk factors don’t fully account for the trend. Scientists suggest other underlying causes may be contributing. Cancer patterns in England are shifting in a [...]
New Immune Pathway Could Supercharge mRNA Cancer Vaccines
A surprising backup system in the immune response to mRNA vaccines may hold the key to more effective cancer treatments. The arrival of mRNA vaccines against SARS-CoV-2 in 2020 marked a turning point in the COVID-19 pandemic. Today, [...]
Scientists Discover “Molecular Switch” That Fuels Alzheimer’s Brain Inflammation
A newly identified trigger of brain inflammation could offer a fresh target for slowing Alzheimer’s progression. The brain has its own built-in immune system that identifies threats and responds to them. In Alzheimer’s disease, growing evidence [...]
Molecular Manufacturing: The Future of Nanomedicine – New book from NanoappsMedical Inc.
This book explores the revolutionary potential of atomically precise manufacturing technologies to transform global healthcare, as well as practically every other sector across society. This forward-thinking volume examines how envisaged Factory@Home systems might enable the cost-effective [...]
Forgotten Medicinal Plant Shows Promise in Fighting Dangerous Superbugs
A traditional medicinal plant, tormentil, shows promise against antibiotic-resistant bacteria in laboratory tests. Its compounds work by limiting bacterial growth and boosting antibiotic performance. Before the development of modern antibiotics, plant-based remedies were commonly [...]
NanoMedical Brain/Cloud Interface – Explorations and Implications. A new book from Frank Boehm
New book from Frank Boehm, NanoappsMedical Inc Founder: This book explores the future hypothetical possibility that the cerebral cortex of the human brain might be seamlessly, safely, and securely connected with the Cloud via [...]















