New research challenges the ease of implanting false memories, highlighting flaws in the influential “Lost in the Mall” study.
By reexamining the data from a previous study, researchers found that many supposed false memories might actually be based on real experiences, casting doubt on the use of such studies in legal contexts.
Reevaluating the “Lost in the Mall” Study
False memories are much harder to implant than previously believed, according to a new study by researchers at UCL and Royal Holloway, University of London.
The 1995 “Lost in the Mall” study has been widely referenced in criminal trials, especially in cases of historical sexual abuse — most notably by Harvey Weinstein’s defense team — to question the reliability of accusers’ memories.
This well-known study suggested that implanting false memories of events that never happened is relatively easy. In the original study, 25% of the 24 participants falsely remembered being lost in a supermarket at the age of five.
In 2023, psychologists from University College Cork and University College Dublin replicated the study using the same methods but with a larger sample of 123 participants. They reported a higher rate of false memories, claiming that 35% of participants recalled the fabricated event.
Scrutiny of Recent Findings
However, a new analysis of the 2023 data, published in Applied Cognitive Psychology, has cast significant doubt on these findings. It revealed that none of the 35% classified as having a false memory fully recalled the fabricated event, and many did not even remember being lost at all.
According to the new analysis, half of those judged to have false memories had actually been lost before and were likely to be reporting on real events (albeit at a different time/place). Meanwhile, others were so unsure about the suggested details in the fake story that their testimony would have been of little value in court.
Implications for Legal Proceedings
Emeritus Professor Chris Brewin (UCL Psychology & Language Sciences) said: “The findings underscore the dangers of applying laboratory research findings to the real world of witnesses in court. People in these studies are cautious in what they claim to remember and seem to be much less likely than the investigators to agree they had a false memory. Experts need to be very careful in how they present research findings so as not to mislead the justice system.”
As part of their analysis, the researchers focused on six core details of the fake event, including: being lost; crying; being helped by an elderly woman; being reunited with their family; the location of the event; the time of the event.
Participant Reliability and Memory
They found that participants who were deemed to have a false memory on average recalled one and a half details with any confidence, and 30% recalled none at all.
This was consistent with previous reports that investigators’ false memory judgments were often not backed up by the views of the participants themselves.
Lead author Emeritus Professor Bernice Andrews (Royal Holloway Department of Psychology) added: “This is the first time that the raw data from a false memory implantation study have been made publicly available and subjected to independent scrutiny.”
Reference: “Lost in the Mall? Interrogating Judgements of False Memory” by Bernice Andrews and Chris R. Brewin, 12 December 2024, Applied Cognitive Psychology.
DOI: 10.1002/acp.70012
News
Study identifies new targets for antiviral drugs against coronaviruses
A study led by researchers at the University of California San Diego School of Medicine and University of California, Riverside (UCR) School of Medicine has identified new targets for antiviral drugs against coronaviruses, including [...]
“Nearly Everybody Had Given Up” – Scientists Finally Solve a 60-Year Chemistry Mystery
After more than six decades of failed attempts, chemists have achieved a breakthrough involving a class of molecules long considered too unstable to isolate. Chemists have succeeded in isolating a group of molecules that [...]
Depression Symptoms Improved in Just 48 Hours After a Single Psychedelic Dose
A single dose of psilocybin produced rapid antidepressant effects in a small Swedish clinical trial, with improvements lasting for weeks. A single dose of psilocybin, the psychedelic compound found in magic mushrooms, produced rapid [...]
GHCE Concept
From the preface of the book Global Health Care Equivalency in the Age of Nanotechnology, Nanomedicine and Artificial Intelligence, Edited by Frank Boehm: Since the publication of my first book (Nanomedical Device and Systems [...]
Human Bodies Are Producing Two Billion Tons of CO2 a Year
A new study reveals that the amount of carbon dioxide produced by human metabolism has increased dramatically over three decades. The carbon dioxide produced by human bodies as they convert food into energy increased [...]
A Hidden DNA Mechanism Could Explain How 20% of Human Cancers Develop
Researchers have identified an unexpected molecular vulnerability in cancers carrying BAF mutations. Mutations found in roughly 20% of human cancers may promote tumor growth by changing how DNA is organized inside cells. Researchers have [...]
Ebola kills over 5,300 in fastest-growing outbreak on record
Africa’s latest Ebola outbreak has killed nearly 5,400 people, the vast majority of them in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), according to the continent’s top health agency. Africa Centres for Disease Control and [...]
China makes early progress in using sound waves to stimulate damaged brains
Chinese researchers are testing whether focused ultrasound can help restore consciousness in patients with severe brain injuries, adding to a growing international effort to use sound waves to stimulate deep brain structures without surgery. [...]
Micro-drones fly through the body thanks to ultrasound
At the EPFL, micro-drones have been developed that can be moved without a motor or battery.No motors, no batteries, no electronics on board, just small cavities that convert sound waves into thrust: this is [...]
A Single Enzyme Could Hold the Key to Treating a Devastating Brain Disorder
Blocking an enzyme’s production restored brain growth and healthy behaviors in mice engineered to develop Angelman syndrome, pointing to a possible treatment target. Children with Angelman syndrome begin to show difficulties with thinking and [...]
Scientists Develop a Clever New Way To Kill Cancer Cells From the Inside
Scientists have developed an experimental strategy that exploits a chemical byproduct of cancer cells to produce anticancer drugs directly inside them. Scientists in Japan have developed an experimental method that uses a chemical produced [...]
Our books are available worldwide!
Online Sellers other than Amazon, Routledge, and IOPP Indigo Global Health Care Equivalency in the Age of Nanotechnology, Nanomedicine and Artifcial Intelligence Global Health Care Equivalency In The Age Of Nanotechnology, Nanomedicine And Artificial [...]
After only a short training, people in a coma managed to send targeted signals
Researchers have succeeded in communicating with brain-injured patients who are unconscious. They see enormous potential in this for future treatments. Patients who lie motionless in bed after a severe brain injury and do not [...]
MIT Scientists Reprogram Immune Cells Inside the Body To Destroy Cancer
Natural killer cells reprogrammed inside mice eliminated lymphoma tumors and helped damaged livers heal, though whether this approach could help people with cancer or autoimmune disease remains unknown. To make a cancer treatment from [...]
Melanoma mRNA Vaccine Shows Promise in Preventing Disease Recurrence
Key takeaways: Phase 3 trial finds personalized intismeran plus pembrolizumab may better prevent high-risk melanoma recurrence after surgery The trial enrolled 1,137 patients and builds on phase 2 results showing about half the recurrence [...]
Scientists Discover a Powerful New Weapon Against a Dangerous Gut Infection
The promise of an experimental treatment for C. difficile gut infections lies partly in the bacteria it leaves alive, according to early laboratory and mouse research. Broad-spectrum antibiotics can disrupt the gut’s microbial community, [...]
