Doctors experimenting with AI tools to help diagnose patients is nothing new. But getting them to trust the AIs they’re using is another matter entirely.
To establish that trust, researchers at Cornell University attempted to create a more transparent AI system that works by counseling doctors in the same way a human colleague would — that is, arguing over what the medical literature says.







Their resulting study, which will be presented at the Association for Computing Machinery Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems later this month, found that how a medical AI works isn’t nearly as important to earning a doctor’s trust as the sources it cites in its suggestions.
“A doctor’s primary job is not to learn how AI works,” said Qian Yang, an assistant professor of information science at Cornell who led the study, in a press release. “If we can build systems that help validate AI suggestions based on clinical trial results and journal articles, which are trustworthy information for doctors, then we can help them understand whether the AI is likely to be right or wrong for each specific case.”
“We built a system that basically tries to recreate the interpersonal communication that we observed when the doctors give suggestions to each other, and fetches the same kind of evidence from clinical literature to support the AI’s suggestion,” Yang said.
The AI tool Yang’s team created is based on GPT-3, an older large language model that once powered OpenAI’s ChatGPT. The tool’s interface is fairly straightforward: on one side, it provides the AI’s suggestions. The other side contrasts this with relevant biomedical literature the AI gleaned, plus brief summaries of each study and other helpful nuggets of information like patient outcomes.
So far, the team has developed their tool with three different medical specializations: neurology, psychiatry, and palliative care. When the doctors tried the versions tailored to their respective field, they told the researchers that they liked the presentation of the medical literature, and affirmed they preferred it to an explanation of how the AI worked.
Either way, this specialized AI seems to be faring better than ChatGPT’s attempt of playing the doctor in a larger study, which found that 60 percent of its answers to real medical scenarios disagreed with human experts’ opinions or were too irrelevant to be helpful.
But the jury is still out on how the Cornell researchers’ AI would hold up when subjected to a similar analysis.
Overall, it’s worth noting that while these tools may be helpful to doctors who have years of expertise to inform their decisions, we’re still a very long way out from an “AI medical advisor” that can replace them.
News
Our books are available worldwide!
Online Sellers other than Amazon, Routledge, and IOPP Indigo Global Health Care Equivalency in the Age of Nanotechnology, Nanomedicine and Artifcial Intelligence Global Health Care Equivalency In The Age Of Nanotechnology, Nanomedicine And Artificial [...]
Scientists Discover a Surprising New Power of Honey That Could Protect Your Skin
Honey’s medical uses may go beyond healing wounds, as laboratory experiments suggest multifloral honey could strengthen human skin cells’ defenses against damaging UV radiation. Ultraviolet (UV) radiation from sunlight can accelerate skin aging and [...]
Scientists Discover That Male and Female Hearts Age in Surprisingly Different Ways
A new study reveals surprising differences in how male and female hearts age at the cellular level. The heart may age very differently from one region to another. A detailed study of mouse hearts [...]
An Ancient Virus May Hold the Secret to What Makes the Human Brain Different
Could a virus that infected chimpanzees millions of years ago help explain how the human brain became different? Researchers at Lund University have discovered that ancient viral DNA embedded in the chimpanzee genome silences [...]
Could a Nasal Spray Stop Alzheimer’s Before Memory Loss Begins?
Protecting memory from Alzheimer’s may one day involve a nasal spray, with encouraging results in animals and evidence that its particles also protect human neurons grown in the lab. Alzheimer’s disease damages the connections [...]
A sceptical guide to AI agents in drug discovery
In conversation with Dr Eric Ma, Senior Principal Data Scientist at Moderna, Dr Raminderpal Singh examines what AI agents are actually good for, where the lock-in hides and why expertise has become more valuable [...]
Study identifies new targets for antiviral drugs against coronaviruses
A study led by researchers at the University of California San Diego School of Medicine and University of California, Riverside (UCR) School of Medicine has identified new targets for antiviral drugs against coronaviruses, including [...]
“Nearly Everybody Had Given Up” – Scientists Finally Solve a 60-Year Chemistry Mystery
After more than six decades of failed attempts, chemists have achieved a breakthrough involving a class of molecules long considered too unstable to isolate. Chemists have succeeded in isolating a group of molecules that [...]
Depression Symptoms Improved in Just 48 Hours After a Single Psychedelic Dose
A single dose of psilocybin produced rapid antidepressant effects in a small Swedish clinical trial, with improvements lasting for weeks. A single dose of psilocybin, the psychedelic compound found in magic mushrooms, produced rapid [...]
GHCE Concept
From the preface of the book Global Health Care Equivalency in the Age of Nanotechnology, Nanomedicine and Artificial Intelligence, Edited by Frank Boehm: Since the publication of my first book (Nanomedical Device and Systems [...]
Human Bodies Are Producing Two Billion Tons of CO2 a Year
A new study reveals that the amount of carbon dioxide produced by human metabolism has increased dramatically over three decades. The carbon dioxide produced by human bodies as they convert food into energy increased [...]
A Hidden DNA Mechanism Could Explain How 20% of Human Cancers Develop
Researchers have identified an unexpected molecular vulnerability in cancers carrying BAF mutations. Mutations found in roughly 20% of human cancers may promote tumor growth by changing how DNA is organized inside cells. Researchers have [...]
Ebola kills over 5,300 in fastest-growing outbreak on record
Africa’s latest Ebola outbreak has killed nearly 5,400 people, the vast majority of them in the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), according to the continent’s top health agency. Africa Centres for Disease Control and [...]
China makes early progress in using sound waves to stimulate damaged brains
Chinese researchers are testing whether focused ultrasound can help restore consciousness in patients with severe brain injuries, adding to a growing international effort to use sound waves to stimulate deep brain structures without surgery. [...]
Micro-drones fly through the body thanks to ultrasound
At the EPFL, micro-drones have been developed that can be moved without a motor or battery.No motors, no batteries, no electronics on board, just small cavities that convert sound waves into thrust: this is [...]
A Single Enzyme Could Hold the Key to Treating a Devastating Brain Disorder
Blocking an enzyme’s production restored brain growth and healthy behaviors in mice engineered to develop Angelman syndrome, pointing to a possible treatment target. Children with Angelman syndrome begin to show difficulties with thinking and [...]















