In a recent study published in PLoS Computational Biology, researchers used mathematical modelling to evaluate whether prioritizing older individuals for coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) booster vaccinations consistently leads to optimal public health outcomes across diverse socio-economic settings.
In the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic, non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) were crucial in reducing transmission and protecting healthcare systems.
The introduction of vaccines, such as those from Pfizer-BioNTech, Oxford-AstraZeneca, and Moderna, significantly altered the pandemic’s trajectory by reducing severe cases and relaxing NPIs.
However, immunity from these vaccines wanes over time, necessitating booster vaccinations, especially with emerging variants.
Further research is needed to refine booster vaccination strategies to address varying population structures and socio-economic contexts globally, ensuring the most effective public health outcomes.
About the study
The study extends a previously published age-structured compartmental model of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) transmission and vaccination.
This deterministic model, governed by ordinary differential equations, divides individuals into compartments based on age, current infection status, and immune status before any infection.
The model includes 16 age groups, with individuals classified as Susceptible, Exposed, Infectious (symptomatic or asymptomatic), or Recovered.
To more accurately represent the time spent in the exposed class, the model employs gamma distributions, which provide a realistic representation of epidemiological periods.
The model also tracks immune status, categorizing individuals into groups such as Vaccinated, Boosted, Partially Waned, Fully Waned, and Unvaccinated, reflecting their infection and vaccination history.
The effectiveness of vaccination is incorporated into the model, accounting for reduced risks of infection, symptoms, hospitalization, and death.
Using this model, the study examines the impacts of six different age-based booster vaccination strategies across eight countries. Strategy 1 prioritizes the oldest individuals first, while Strategy 6 explores vaccinating those with the most contacts to provide indirect protection to the elderly.
Strategies 2-5 test variations of these approaches, generally focusing on prioritizing older individuals for booster vaccination. The analysis assumes limited vaccine availability, with a 10% population coverage baseline and a 90% maximum uptake per age group.
Study results
The population’s age structure varies significantly across countries, with high-income countries generally having a larger proportion of older individuals compared to low-income countries.
This demographic difference influences the distribution of booster vaccines under different vaccination strategies. In the UK, for instance, strategies 1-4 that prioritize older individuals for booster vaccination result in a substantial number of individuals aged 50-74 receiving vaccines. However, the oldest individuals (75+) may not be fully covered due to the limited vaccine supply.
On the other hand, Strategies focused on vaccinating younger individuals, particularly those aged 20-49, who typically have more contacts and, therefore, could potentially contribute to indirect protection of older populations.
However, the age distribution of vaccinated individuals under each strategy varies between countries. For example, in Sierra Leone, where the proportion of older individuals is relatively small, Strategies 1-4 effectively vaccinate almost all older individuals, leading to identical outcomes for these strategies.
This contrasts with the situation in the UK, where a larger elderly population means that not all older individuals can be vaccinated under these strategies due to vaccine constraints.
When considering the impact of these strategies on public health outcomes during a wave of infections caused by a novel SARS-CoV-2 variant, the model projections indicated that Strategy 1 consistently resulted in the fewest deaths across all countries analyzed.
This outcome is particularly evident in high-income countries, where a large proportion of older individuals contribute to a higher projected number of deaths if they are not prioritized for booster vaccination.
In contrast, in countries like Sierra Leone, the small number of older individuals allows nearly all of them to receive booster vaccines under Strategy 1, leading to fewer deaths overall.
The analysis also examined the projected Years of Life Lost (YLL), which accounts for the number of deaths and the ages at which they occur.
While it might be expected that vaccinating younger individuals could reduce YLL, the model consistently showed that Strategy 1, which prioritizes the oldest individuals, was optimal in minimizing YLL. This is due to the higher risk of severe outcomes and mortality associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection in older populations.
Sensitivity analyses further supported these findings, showing that Strategy 1 led to fewer deaths and YLL under various assumptions, including different levels of vaccine availability, uptake rates, and timing of booster administration.
Even when the outbreak began 150 days after booster vaccines were administered, resulting in some immunity waning, Strategy 1 remained the most effective approach in reducing deaths and YLL.
Conclusions
To summarize, future SARS-CoV-2 transmission will be influenced by novel variants, booster vaccinations, and immunity dynamics. Unlike the pandemic’s early stages, many individuals globally are now infected or vaccinated, impacting immunity and transmission.
In this evolving scenario, it is essential to reassess the effectiveness of past interventions and explore new strategies.
This study evaluated different age-based booster vaccination strategies and found that prioritizing older individuals consistently leads to better public health outcomes, regardless of varying population structures.
- Bouros I, Hill EM, Keeling MJ, et al. (2024) Prioritizing older individuals for COVID-19 booster vaccination leads to optimal public health outcomes in a range of socio-economic settings. PLoS Comput Biol. doi:https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. pcbi.1012309. https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?
News
How Missing Sleep Lets Bad Memories Haunt Your Mind
Research reveals that a lack of sleep can hinder the brain’s ability to suppress unwanted memories and intrusive thoughts, emphasizing the importance of restful sleep for mental health. Sleep deprivation has been found to [...]
WHO issues new warning over ‘mystery virus’ and calls for return of COVID restrictions
The World Health Organization (WHO) has called for the reinstatement of restrictions implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic as cases of human metapneumovirus (HMPV) continue to surge. While hospitals in China are overwhelmed with positive [...]
A Breath Away From a Cure: How Xenon Gas Could Transform Alzheimer’s Treatment
A breakthrough study highlights Xenon gas as a potential game-changer in treating Alzheimer’s disease, demonstrating its ability to mitigate brain damage and improve cognitive functions in mouse models. A forthcoming clinical trial aims to test its [...]
False Memories Under Fire: Surprising Science Behind What We Really Recall
New research challenges the ease of implanting false memories, highlighting flaws in the influential “Lost in the Mall” study. By reexamining the data from a previous study, researchers found that many supposed false memories [...]
Born Different? Cambridge Scientists Uncover Innate Sex Differences in Brains
Cambridge researchers found that sex differences in brain structure exist from birth, with males having more white matter and females more grey matter, highlighting early neurodiversity. Research from the Autism Research Centre at the University [...]
New study shows risk factors for dementia – virus causes deposits in the brain
Research into the causes of Alzheimer's is not yet complete. Now a new study shows that head trauma can activate herpes viruses and promote the disease. Frankfurt am Main – As a neurodegenerative disease, [...]
Are Machines Truly Thinking? Modern AI Systems Have Finally Achieved Turing’s Vision
Modern AI systems have fulfilled Turing’s vision of machines that learn and converse like humans, but challenges remain. A new paper highlights concerns about energy consumption and societal inequality while calling for more robust [...]
The Surprising Link Between Smell, Sound, and Emotions
New research reveals how smell and hearing interact in the brain to drive social behavior, using mouse maternal instincts as a model. Imagine you’re at a dinner party, but you can’t smell the food [...]
Brain cells age at different rates
As our body ages, not only joints, bones and muscles wear out, but also our nervous system. Nerve cells die, are no longer fully replaced, and the brain shrinks. "Aging is the most important risk factor [...]
Long COVID Breakthrough: Spike Proteins Persist in Brain for Years
Researchers have discovered that the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein persists in the brain and skull bone marrow for years after infection, potentially leading to chronic inflammation and neurodegenerative diseases. Researchers from Helmholtz Munich and Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität (LMU) have [...]
Water-Resistant Paper Could Revolutionize Packaging and Replace Plastic
A groundbreaking study showcases the creation of sustainable hydrophobic paper, enhanced by cellulose nanofibres and peptides, presenting a biodegradable alternative to petroleum-based materials, with potential uses in packaging and biomedical devices. Researchers aimed to [...]
NIH Scientists Discover Game-Changing Antibodies Against Malaria
Novel antibodies have the potential to pave the way for the next generation of malaria interventions. Researchers at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) have identified a novel class of antibodies that target a previously unexplored region [...]
Surprising Discovery: What If Some Cancer Genes Are Actually Protecting You?
A surprising discovery reveals that a gene previously thought to accelerate esophageal cancer actually helps protect against it initially. This pivotal study could lead to better prediction and prevention strategies tailored to individual genetic [...]
The Cancer Test That Exposes What Conventional Scans Miss
Researchers at UCLA have unveiled startling findings using PSMA-PET imaging that reveal nearly half of patients diagnosed with high-risk prostate cancer might actually have metastases missed by traditional imaging methods. This revelation could profoundly affect future [...]
Pupil size in sleep reveals how memories are processed
Cornell University researchers have found that the pupil is key to understanding how, and when, the brain forms strong, long-lasting memories. By studying mice equipped with brain electrodes and tiny eye-tracking cameras, the researchers [...]
Stanford’s Vaccine Breakthrough Boosts Flu Protection Like Never Before
Stanford Medicine researchers have developed a new method for influenza vaccination that encourages a robust immune response to all four common flu subtypes, potentially increasing the vaccine’s efficacy. In laboratory tests using human tonsil [...]
